Once again, the headline read “building slated for demolition.” This time it was another piece of our heritage that had not outlived its usefulness, but found itself situated in a time and place where the few who did care were powerless to stem the results of neglect. The absentee landlords had won. Were we losing touch with our roots?
The site of the Garman Building sits at the crossroads of two significant streets in Blair County. Pennsylvania Avenue and Tenth Street in the small city of Tyrone, Pennsylvania, at one time played a tremendous role in the financial success of our growing country. This essay is about the Garman Building and a little of what went on inside of this building. It is also to highlight a few of the neighbors who went about their daily business near this corner.
Tracing the Roots
When research started on this story, the author was perplexed. Where does one begin? A stack of deeds existed and they were in chronological order. After reading back through these, we get closer to the time when Tyrone was first charted, 1851. Then, on the bottom of the pile, we start to see the names of our first founders, Burley, Lyon, Stewart, Shorb, Dallas, Bell, and Matthias.
Finally, a deed is uncovered that ceases to reference building dimensions. It describes the empty land and its marking points are specific trees! Fifty paces from a strong maple, turn, commence a right angle to a large pine. We are reading about the territory on which our folklore states Burley and Stewart threw up a shanty on Christmas Day in 1850. Within months, wagon loads of iron workers arrived to stake a lot for a home. So it was on these four corners of the then named Juniata (Tenth Street) and Main (Pennsylvania Avenue) that this unnamed village in Snyder Township would progress.
The Bellefonte Connection
One may ask, “What does Bellefonte have to do with Tyrone’s history?” Yet when the first two years of Tyrone history are examined, it becomes apparent that even though the new public works railroad put in place by the State of Pennsylvania rolled right past this village, there were no plans for a depot. Town folks had to walk the mile down the old wagon road to Tyrone Forge to board a train. Meanwhile, on the upper end of the Bald Eagle Valley, the old and beautiful borough of Bellefonte was struggling to become a part of Pennsylvania’s expansion.
Bellefonte, an early iron producer, was isolated on the end of the West Branch system of the Susquehanna. Connected by canal and primeval roads, it had developed into a seat of learned individuals and beautiful homes. With a rail system at the opposite end of the Bald Eagle path, entrepreneurs took note. Somehow there had to be a connection made to get iron and lumber to market through this valley.
A company was formed and bonds were sold at Tyrone to fund the building of The Tyrone Bellefonte Turnpike. This mid-century marvel was a plank road of creosote soaked ties butted together. It ran up Main to Glen Street (later Fifteenth Street) and left town at a diagonal northwest direction. A toll gate stood at Deckers Run. The enormous amount of lumber for this thirty mile project was supplied by a lumberyard in Unionville, Centre County. The old Penn Central road company (in 1857 this became PRR) took note of this activity and in 1853, a wooden Gothic Style station was placed at the head of Pennsylvania Avenue.
Operating seven years, the plank road did not garner the profits expected; however, it made others aware of how strategic this valley was for transporting goods. By the end of the 1850s two rail projects were pushing forward through the Bald Eagle Valley. In time, Tyrone City began receiving new residents from these newly accessible territories.
Banking, Tyrone’s Financial Growth
In the 1860s Tyrone grew steadily. In 1866, Lloyd, Caldwell and Company opened a Lloyd bank in Tyrone; the first banking institution to locate here. Thomas J. Caldwell built an expansive home on South Lincoln Avenue, which was featured in Godey’s Lady’s Book; the most circulated national magazine of the era. Mr. Caldwell was replaced after his unexpected death in 1867 by his son David T. Caldwell who took charge of affairs until the bank was consumed in the financial panic of 1873.
Yet, Tyrone was not without a bank. Leading up to the panic, in what would eventually be named the Garman Building, a private bank of individual liability had formed in 1871 and began transacting business as Tyrone Bank. In 1873 this institution rode the tide of uncertainty and survived to continue operating. Tyrone Bank moved to the former Caldwell offices in 1876.
The 1880s and 1890s saw enormous growth in the financial value of investing in Tyrone’s business affairs. This was also a time when per capita and square mileage placed Tyrone as the most densely populated town in Blair County. The Morrison & Cass & Company Paper Mill began operation in 1880 and was soon one of the largest of its type in the state.
In 1890, the First National Bank opened its doors in the Garman Building. Its board of directors was a Who’s Who of Tyrone’s business community. The president was J. K. Cass who also partnered at the paper mill as a director. The bank’s directors were I. P. Walton, vice president; D. S. Kloss, cashier; A. A. Stevens, Jacob H. Mattern, John A. Crawford, and Adie D. Mingle.
The Garman Family
In Bellefonte, the David and Louisa (Shreyer) Garman family had nine children. The family name appeared on three businesses in that town. It still hangs on the Garman House building in Bellefonte’s celebrated Victorian business district. Their son, Allen, built and managed the Garman Opera House in 1888.
In 1898, two Garman brothers came to Tyrone to live and enter the business community. Allen S. Garman bought the Empire Hotel on Eleventh Street and Pennsylvania Avenue. He renamed this hostelry the Garman House. The other brother, Robert Tipple Garman, apprenticed as a jeweler in Bellefonte where he practiced the trade for five years.
In a few years, William “Harvey” Garman (no relation to the Bellefonte Garmans) came from Indiana County and opened a business that would outlive the other Garman businesses. Along with his wife Lillian, they opened the Garman Department Store at 1004 Pennsylvania. The business became a family affair when the name changed to Garman and Sons. This Garman concern was still in business in the early 1970s with Lillian at the helm on the opposite side of the avenue at 1014.
The Jewelry Business
In Tyrone, Robert T. Garman, upon arriving from Bellefonte, bought out the entire stock and business of George H. Garner on Pennsylvania Avenue in 1898. Tyrone merchants had a long tradition of providing the public with first class jewelry. Isaac Walton began the practice in 1859 and later promoted an engraver and watchmaker in his employ to be his partner. Walton and Acklin, and later simply Acklin Jewelry Company, had the reputation of storing the largest selection of diamonds in the state, outside of Philadelphia and Pittsburgh.
This was a time when all men carried a time piece on a gold chain and sleeves required cuff links. Fashionable women were presented with all types of jewelry and never seen outside of the home without a broach and several rings. The jeweler was also a person to consult about table service. As men became vested in their professions, silverware for the dining room and cut glass throughout the house reflected their change in status.
In 1897 there were five jewelry outlets in Tyrone. J. A. C. Stewart occupied the Stewart building on Tenth Street and J. W. Stewart maintained a business on the second floor of the Conrad building. Samuel Widney was located at 11 E Twelfth Street.
Biographical information for R. T. Garman was published in 1911 as follows: “Mr. Garman, born January 14, 1875, was married May 18, 1904, to Miss Virginia Bouse, a daughter of W. A. Bouse, who is trainmaster for the Pennsylvania Railroad, at Tyrone. They have three children: Robert, Rebecca West and Virginia Schroyer. Mr. and Mrs. Garman are members of Trinity Episcopal Church at Tyrone, in which Mr. Garman is a vestryman. He is a member of the Business Men’s Association and of the Tyrone Country Club. Mr. Garman is a Democrat.”
A Building of His Own
In 1905 the board members of the First National Bank announced that one of Tyrone’s oldest buildings, the Study property at 1000 Pennsylvania Avenue, would be razed and the bank would be constructing new quarters.
James A. Study built Tyrone’s largest place of business in 1858. Study Dry Goods Store had four large show room windows that were always done up with merchandise to stop shoppers. Expansive rooms on the second floor displayed carpets and wall hangings. Study’s was a precursor to the emporiums and department stores that would become popular in Tyrone in the 1870s. By 1900 the Study Building had become dated.
The new building, the four story Jones Building, was designed by award winning architects. The Beezer Brothers firm of Pittsburgh shipped the precut stones and the various components of the massive structure to Tyrone on rail cars. They were ceremoniously hauled by dray wagons from the depot to the staging site for assembly.
With the vacating of the South West corner of the square in 1906, R. T. Garman purchased the old First National Bank building and installed one of the largest stocks of fine jewelry in the region. With a brother Ira in the jewelry business in Philadelphia, he perhaps had an edge on purchasing better gemstones.
The Garman stock included gold and silver articles, together with precious stones, clocks, watches and porcelains. With the recent use of electric lighting in homes, he specialized in upscale fixtures that made his showroom sparkle. His front display window extended out over the sidewalk with glass sides. His competitors could not top this arrangement. His crowning touch to update this decades-old building was to have a local tinsmith construct a cornice with the Garman name in three-dimensional letters.
Robert T. Garman remained a fixture in the business community until 1950, shortly before his death in July of that year.
The 1936 flood hit Tyrone and caused $2 million in damages (that translates to $31.3 million in 2009 dollars). This was the worst disaster to hit Pennsylvania and Garman’s Jewelry stock was destroyed. Mr. Garman arrived after the waters receded to find his tooling bench pushed through the window. The remnants were salvaged, but Robert Garman did not regain all of his spirits after this. He still did excellent work, but he scaled back advertising and let others, such as Simms at 20 West Tenth Street and Acklin’s at 1057-63 Pennsylvania Avenue take some of his customer base.
Other Businesses Near the Corner
Robert T. Garman did not occupy his whole building. With his house at 306 West 11th Street, he rented space above and on the ground floor to others. Two suites were designed for those of the dental profession. Dr. Thaddeus Stine and Elmer Crawford were among those of this profession. Hicks and Templeton, Attorneys, had a law office above the First National Bank.
Most buildings on Pennsylvania Avenue had “walk up businesses” on the second, and many times, on the third floor. Windows had gold lettering identifying the occupants. Since the first level many times had high ceilings, the steps to the second were a long climb. The Jones Building had an elevator, as did the Farmers and Merchants bank. The third floor of the Garman Building was used by the Elks Club and the Masonic organization before they moved to the Boecking Building on West Tenth Street. Subsequently, they built their own building on Eleventh Street and Pennsylvania Avenue in 1930.
The Times
Prior to Garman Jewelry and between banking businesses, the Tyrone Times used the corner building for a short time. Formed in 1880 by J. N. Holmes and A. M. Wooden this weekly newspaper moved to a larger press building constructed near the depot. H. A. Thompson took over production and The Times was around for 60 years, being absorbed by the Herald in 1940.
Fye Drugs had a pharmacy for some time at the Garman building. Fye was one business that had molds fabricated to be used at the Tyrone Glass Factory, at Cold Spring Forge just South of the present borough. This factory can be given credit for creating many of the old bottles now found that have Tyrone businesses embossed in the glass. Fifty employees found jobs here in the 1890s.
Candy, Cigars, Etc.
Aaron L. Koons manufactured candy in the building adjoining the Garman Building on Tenth Street. From the basement to the third floor, the Koons establishment manufactured and boxed fine chocolates. On the ground floor there was a retail store with fruit, nuts and candies. Koons went into business in 1868 and continued for over 40 years. Koons probably apprenticed under Zerby Candies, which began in 1862.
Although many think of J. Gardner and Company when it comes to candy, Koons as well as McCormick and Musser had the larger operations for many years. McCormick Candy Works was on Highland Drive above the depot. Their building eventually was consumed by Wilson Chemical Company and the spot was renamed Cloverine Terrace.
When Koons ceased operation as a candy maker, it appears that he retired and Koons was listed as a travel agent at 13 East 10th Street. R. J. Kingston advertised his billiard parlor at 7 East 10th Street as being first class. Billiard parlors always sold cigars. Many times the proprietor of the parlor owned stock in the cigar company. In the early 1900s there were nine stores that sold cigars in Tyrone, three billiard parlors and there were two cigar manufacturers in Tyrone. Those two were Jewel Cigar Company on the corner of 11th and Bald Eagle Avenue and E. C. Poorman at 210 East 10th Street. Many of Tyrone’s political decisions were debated in billiard halls.
Other Ventures
In the 1900s at 9 East 10th Street Sprankle Brothers maintained a large meat market that specialized in fresh pork products and salted meats. Their rendered lard was put up in little gold pails featuring the Sprankle name. At the same time, their second store was located at 14th Street and Pennsylvania Avenue which later was occupied by Hikes Grocery. In 1911, there were over 31 grocery stores conducting business in Tyrone. The Sprankle hogs were raised on a homestead along Hoovers Lane.
In the 1930s, the Panasiti family opened a grocery at 9 East and eventually expanded down the block as they transformed their interests into the renowned Villa Restaurant bar and lounge with banquet facilities. 11 East Tenth Street was occupied by Klevansky Dry Goods in the 1900s.
Just a Stone’s Throw from Tyrone
From Tyrone’s inception, the excavation of limestone has played a major role in the local economy. Originally there was some excavation at Stoney Point and along the Bald Eagle Creek at the end of Pennsylvania Avenue, but major veins of exceptionally pure limestone were found near Stover Station and Tyrone Forge. Morris Quarries began operation in 1870 and led the nation in output. 125 carloads of stone left Tyrone daily from this location alone. 300 men were employed by Morris in 1897.
A. A. Stevens’ venture into stone was located at Union Furnace. His output was 150 carloads shipped per day along with 2500 bushels of pure lime. Lime for farms and for concrete mix. Cut stone was used for building. Lime also was used by the chemical industry, glass works, and furnace fluxing and lining. The railroad purchased crushed stone for ballast and when the highway system began in the 1910s, stone and gravel became a new demand.
Most of this activity was out of view of the average citizen; however, the quarries maintained offices in Tyrone and the owners were on the boards of the three banks. Arthur Vanneman and his wife Letitia came to Tyrone in 1912 to work for Tyrone Water and Gas. He became interested in stone through his association with A. A. Stevens. Vanneman bought out holdings of a few companies and eventually consolidated operations forming Tyrone Stone and Lime. Mr. Vanneman died in 1940. His wife eventually turned over control to their son John Robert Vanneman who had married Gretchen Garman, daughter of R. T. Garman. The office for Tyrone Stone and Lime was at 954 Pennsylvania Avenue, however, when the jewelry business closed, Tyrone Stone used their storeroom for offices.
Later Activity
Long’s Dairy bought out Charlie Waple’s Dairies in the early 1950s. In addition to their plant on 9th Street, an office was located in the Garman Building Showroom managed by Ed Crain. His family name had been associated with the grocery trade for a century. Mr. Crain was also an employee of First Blair County National Bank. Long’s opened two popular dairy stores, one on First Street and Washington Avenue and one in Greenwood.
In the early 1970s a discount shoe store opened in the Garman Building. Some may remember after Tropical Storm Agnes in 1972, the mountain of ruined shoes piled on the corner of Tenth Street.
In 1975, Tyrone welcomed native Dolores (Duey) Dihrberg’s return to Tyrone on the retirement of her husband Arnold. They opened a used book store in the Garman showroom. Dee’s Book Nook was the first of its type to open in decades in Tyrone. Hobbies were a specialty of Dolores. A large display case contained collectable coins for sale. The Book Nook was in operation for over five years.
Over the years since 1980 there have been various businesses with some success operating out of the Garman space. A consignment dress shop was one of these. When the Wing Shop closed, many of the fixtures were transferred here. Ironically, Acklin Jewelry had owned some of these same display cases.
Charles DeFerie Building
Now that the Garman building is history, the end of this once bustling row is the DeFerie building, named after a former owner who opened a tobacco shop that also sold candy. In the 1920s, List’s Restaurant located here and was a busy, as well as popular, destination. Eventually, John List and his wife Amanda took a go at the hotel business and in the 1930s and 1940s Lists was in the Arlington Hotel at Tenth and Logan Avenue. In 1948 there were 13 cafes listed in the Tyrone directory.
During WWII, the DeFerie building showroom was converted into The Waring Canteen, supported by the great showman, Fred Waring. A large parlor was decorated with donated furniture and became a place for enlisted men passing through to have a nice place to relax. With its proximity to the depot, it was a center of activity. After the war, Knepp & Niel men’s clothing store located here for a number of years. Tony’s Bar and Grill later occupied the DeFerie space.
Engelman’s
About 1915 Adolph and Marie Engelman bought green houses from Frank Arnold on West 12th Street and Clay Avenue. Mr. Arnold had been operating at this location since 1882 when his and four other families emigrated from Bavaria to Tyrone. Adolph Engelman soon opened a downtown location separate from the greenhouses at 107 W. 10th Street. A later shop in the Masonic Building at 1103 Pennsylvania Avenue gave way to urban renewal and resulted in a move to the DeFerie building by William Engelman, Adolph’s son, in 1976. When the Engelman business folded in recent years, a legacy of over 120 years came to a close.
Moving Forward
The DeFerie building will probably face the same fate as the Garman building. With absentee landlords, a massive highway project, fire and floods, and the faith in a redevelopment authority in the 1970s, Tyrone has seen easily close to a thousand structures meet their end. Over a third of our town vanished between 1968 and 1978. From the removal of the Academy of Music to small wooden rail industry buildings, we have lost pieces of our heritage.
Although Tyrone is not unique to this progression, it has suffered more than other communities. Since citizens feel powerless to curtail this progression, the best they can do is enthusiastically document our past for coming generations.
Post Scripts and Incidentals
The morning the First National Bank of Tyrone moved into its new quarters, the news was out. The banking officials waited anxiously that day to tally the largest new account deposit. The bank cashier was astounded when a $10,000.00 check fell out of an envelope from Drexell Corporation of Philadelphia, beating out all new depositors.
The Curtin Family of Bellefonte became good friends with business associate Charles Waple. Charles Waple managed three different hotels in Tyrone, including the Ward House for a number of years. He also invested in dairy cows and opened a large dairy on the end of Logan Avenue at Ninth Street. Charles Jr. (Bus Waple) visited often with the surviving Mrs. Curtin, who treated him as family. On one visit in the late 1930s, she surprised Bus with the keys to the Curtin limousine. Bus returned to Tyrone driving a Duesenberg. With two small children at home and a young wife, the Duesenberg ended up in a museum.
An unusual product was distributed by at least three different Tyrone sources. After 1910 Wilson Chemical added a nationally sold line of perfumes to the long list of products bearing their name. The Barr Family in the 1920s and 1930s advertised Barr Parfum, produced from their chemical facility in Tyrone. And, Wayne Farrend of Logan Avenue dealt chemicals in a mail order business from his home. He delighted the ladies lunching at the Elks’ club with gifts of little vials of perfume that he synthesized. An urban legend circulated that he patented Chanel No. 5.
Frank W. Acklin, known for his superb skills at watch repair and owner of a jewelry firm bearing his name, was typical of most Tyrone businessmen during his generation. Acklin served as president of the Farmer’s and Merchant’s bank for a time. He was vice president and director of the Tyrone Gas and Water Company. And, he served as director of the Mishler Theatre Company. He is also the person who introduced apartments to Tyrone. As a large land owner in town, he took a building at Twelfth and Pennsylvania Avenue and designed the upstairs for rental living. Eventually others followed suit.
Share your memories