In the early hours of June 1, 1889, the South Fork Dam let go, causing the Johnstown Flood in which over 10,000 people drowned. It is still the worst natural disaster in the history of the United States. What has gotten lost over time is that the flooding was widespread, and almost every town in western or central Pennsylvania with a river experienced severe flooding, though not to the extent of Johnstown. Gaysport, Duncansville, Clearfield, Huntingdon, Lewistown, Lock Haven, and Williamsport all experienced major flooding and damage, with a particularly huge toll on bridges and railroads.

Tyrone, sitting at the convergence of the Little Juniata and the Bald Eagle Branch of the Juniata, was no exception. Since its founding in 1851, Tyrone had experienced two major floods—but nothing like this. The Tyrone Herald was literally filled with accounts of the damage in Tyrone, while Johnstown got a mere four lines of newsprint on June 1, as it was not yet understood how catastrophic the damage there was.

The night the rivers came up

In Tyrone, after days of heavy rain, the water in Sink Run (coming into town from Janesville Pike) and the two rivers had been rising all day, and at nightfall a fresh deluge of rain caused a sudden swelling of all three streams, sending them over their banks. By 9 p.m. on May 31, Logan, Main, and Spring Streets were underwater, as were Blair and Bald Eagle Streets shortly thereafter. The Brewery Hill section was cut off from the rest of the town. The fire companies moved their apparatus up Ridge Street, and Neptune’s steam pumper was moved to the livery stable of the Arlington Hotel. As the night wore on, John Hunter’s family, on the corner of Berlin Street and Alley K, had to be rescued by the fire department, using ladders.

At the lowest points along Juniata Street, water flooded into the cellars, alleys, and stores, undermining the bricks paving the road. Sink Run ran through a culvert, but blew the top off, isolating a section of Main Street. A wide plank was used when the water receded, until Fred Beyer constructed a temporary wooden bridge to access that area. In Tyrone, railroad bridges in all directions were out; a firehouse was off its foundation, as were many homes. Some people were trapped in their houses all day. Root cellars were underwater, and vegetable crops were lost, not to mention thousands of dollars in damage. A little looting occurred.

The headline in the paper June 1, 1889, was “Great Damage Everywhere—Trees Torn Up by Their Roots—Buildings Swept Away—Streets Torn to Pieces and General Havoc.” Fences were swept away “as readily as chips, barns knocked into every angle of sides but the vertical…gardens and small trees disappeared out of sight. Houses were seen standing halfway below high water, and the inmates driven at an early stage to make a memorable flight, lest their homes might be carried away or forced down during the night and the inmates perish.”

Damage at the mill, the businesses, the rail yards

The railroad yard was underwater and businesses were wrecked. At the paper mill, logs valued at $10,000 were washed down the river, along with the three train cars they were strapped onto; $5,000 in damage was done to the physical property. John S. Morrison, half owner of the paper mill, called in 17 teams of horses and mules to work down the river retrieving the lost pulpwood. He also was the first person to put up $100 and later $30 more to help the people of Johnstown. Tyrone could only muster less than $700 toward relief efforts for Johnstown, as they had big problems of their own. People from Tyrone and Sinking Valley went to Johnstown to assist. Their universal comment was that “there were no words to describe the devastation and horror” they saw. News trickled back of people who had lived in Tyrone who were lost. One lady had nine relatives who drowned.

At the Bald Eagle Tannery in Tyrone, $1,500 in bark and $3,000 in tanning “liquor” was washed away. Samuel Paterson, the marble and granite dealer, had losses of $700–$1,000. Mr. Symington’s wallpaper store lost several hundred dollars in stock. Dr. Burket had a new roof going on his house, and had $1,000 in damage from water pouring into the unfinished portion. The millinery shop had hats ruined; J.S. Smith’s drug store had loss claims of $1,000; Templeton, Crawford & Co, the largest department store, had claims of $500–$900. Grocers, bakeries, merchants—virtually every business downtown—had damage totaling from hundreds to thousands of dollars.

In downtown Tyrone, the water was five feet deep. At some places near the Bald Eagle branch, it rose to seven feet deep. Water at the Juniata Bridge reached fifteen feet above normal level. “The temperance tent was flat as a flounder and covered with mud.” Samuel Patterson’s house was hit with a huge log that burst through one wall, and it took a day before the people inside, who had fled upstairs, could get out. The photocopying house of the Millers was lifted off its foundation and sat in the middle of Allegheny Street. At the Herald office, two inches of water were in the lower floor, even though this was two feet above street level. They still got the paper printed. The firehouse of the Friendship Hook and Ladder Company “floated against the Electric Light Co.’s building nearby.”

A group of stables near the confluence of the two rivers were washed away. Down river at Ironville, all the stables and small buildings, except one, were swept away. One house at Tyrone Forge went down the river and several others were all but destroyed. Railroad Bridge 7 below Birmingham had major damage, and Bridge 13 above Tyrone had one of its abutments collapse.

Bridges, repairs, and very lucky people

Every bridge in Tyrone, clear down to Birmingham was gone, with the exception of the one crossing the Juniata River to the train station; however, it was covered in debris and much weakened. Two spans of the Lewistown and Tyrone bridges to the east were gone. On the Clearfield and Tyrone Line most of the small bridges were badly damaged or washed out. On June 6, a locomotive went through a weakened bridge at Vail and into the river. The locomotive was quickly reclaimed, but the bridge took some time to repair. The railroads did amazing work repairing bridges, and fixing track that had been washed out or undercut. By June 27, the Pennsylvania Railroad had put together an army of 5,000 employees, many borrowed from other railroads, working 16 hours a day on repairs. Bridges that had taken months to build were thrown back up in a week, and by June 20, all the rail lines in and out of Tyrone were pretty much back to normal schedules.

The amazing thing in all this was that no one died. “C.B. McWilliams stepped into a hole and a lot of drift wood struck him at the same time severely throwing him into the current.” He managed to get out, but lost his wallet and the $65 that was in it. “Emerson Fleck got thumped by driftwood in a merciful effort to flee for his life from Fleck’s feed house to Seed’s building.” Everyone whose cellar flooded lost whatever was in there. With all the stables that were washed away and open cesspools under the floodwater, you didn’t want to fool with anything that had been in the water.

It would take months to repair all the streets, fix all the bridges, restock stores, and lime all the basements. But most of all Tyrone was lucky, as every single man who went to help over in Johnstown reported back. Very lucky.

Share your memories

Leave a reply

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.